Skip to main content
History
PASS
History

What was Count Frontenac's famous reply when asked to surrender Québec to the English in 1690?

📖 In-depth explanation

Background, key points, and common pitfalls

Question

What was Count Frontenac's famous reply when asked to surrender Québec to the English in 1690?

📚 Background context

Discover Canada records this defiant moment in a single highlighted block. The guide states that Count Frontenac refused to surrender Quebec to the English in 1690, and gives his exact words in the same caption: "My only reply will be from the mouths of my cannons!" No other reply is offered for this moment by Discover Canada — the answer to memorise is exactly that line.

The wider context helps the line make sense. Discover Canada describes Count Frontenac alongside two other major figures of New France in a separate sentence: Outstanding leaders like Jean Talon, Bishop Laval, and Count Frontenac built a French Empire in North America that reached from Hudson Bay to the Gulf of Mexico. So when the English demanded Quebec's surrender in 1690, the man on the other side of the wall was one of the architects of that French Empire — not a minor garrison commander, but a leader credited by the guide with extending New France across most of the continent.

The reply itself is also significant for what it reveals about the colony's mood. Discover Canada places this caption next to a passage on "a tradition of accommodation," showing both sides of New France's character: a willingness to negotiate and accommodate (as later seen in the Quebec Act of 1774), but also, when pushed, a sharp refusal to surrender. Count Frontenac's words have therefore been remembered as a moment of resolve in the long Anglo-French struggle that ran through the 1600s and 1700s.

🌎 Why this matters today

This is one of Discover Canada's named historical quotations — like "Whereas Canada is founded upon principles that recognize the supremacy of God and the rule of law" from the Charter, or Isaac Brock's example of duty in the War of 1812. The test asks whether new citizens have noticed and remembered such a specific cultural reference.

The 1690 episode also helps anchor the New France timeline. The peace with the Iroquois came in 1701; the British defeat of the French at the Plains of Abraham came in 1759; the Frontenac stand-off at Quebec sits in between, in 1690 — a moment when Discover Canada's account shows the colony was not yet ready to fall.

📜 From Discover Canada

"Count Frontenac refused to surrender Quebec to the English in 1690..."

⚠️ Common misconceptions

1

The peace-negotiation answer choice is wrong. Discover Canada records the opposite: Count Frontenac refused to surrender. There is no negotiation in the guide's account of this 1690 episode.

2

The retreat answer choice is wrong. The guide explicitly describes Count Frontenac as refusing to surrender, not retreating. Discover Canada's caption ends with the cannons reply, not with any retreat.

3

The surrender answer choice is the most-wrong of all. Discover Canada uses the exact word refused in its caption — Count Frontenac did not surrender, and Quebec did not fall to the English in 1690.

4

Don't confuse Count Frontenac (1690 stand-off at Quebec) with the later British–French conflict at the Plains of Abraham in 1759. The French held in 1690 under Count Frontenac; the French lost in 1759 under the Marquis de Montcalm against Brigadier James Wolfe. They are two separate events in Discover Canada.

Key points to remember

Famous reply:
"My only reply will be from the mouths of my cannons!"
Speaker:
Count Frontenac
Year:
1690
Demand:
To surrender Quebec to the English
Outcome:
Refused — Quebec did not fall in 1690
Frontenac's wider role:
One of the "outstanding leaders" who built a French Empire in North America "from Hudson Bay to the Gulf of Mexico"
Other named leaders of New France:
Jean Talon, Bishop Laval
Not to be confused with:
The 1759 Battle of the Plains of Abraham — when the French finally lost Quebec under Marquis de Montcalm to Brigadier James Wolfe

💡 Memory tip

One year, one quote, one man: 1690 · Count Frontenac · "My only reply will be from the mouths of my cannons!". The English demanded surrender; Discover Canada records that Frontenac refused and answered with that famous line. Quebec held in 1690 — and would only fall later, at the Plains of Abraham in 1759.

Premium — Only for the serious you
$9.99 CAD

90-day access · one-time payment By clicking, you agree to our Terms & Refund Policy

Premium Features

PREMIUM

Smart tools to help you study more efficiently